Sick of Michael Moore's sicko propaganda
Is all that ails the U.S. health-care system is that it's not run by a
communist dictatorship? That has long been a premise of apologists for
Fidel Castro who extol the virtues of medical care on his totalitarian
Left-wing documentary filmmaker Michael Moore is reviving this Cold War
relic of an argument in his new movie on health care, "Sicko," which
premieres in a few weeks and favorably compares the Cuban health care
system to ours. Moore ostentatiously took a few sick 9/11 workers to
Cuba for care. "If they can do this," Moore told Time magazine,
referring to the Cubans, "we can do it."
All that the Cuban government has done, however, is run a decades-long
propaganda campaign to convince credulous or dishonest people that its
health care system is worth emulating. These people believe — or pretend
to believe for ideological reasons — that a dictatorship can crush a
country's economy and spirit, yet still deliver exemplary medical care.
Cuban health care works only for the select few: If you are a
high-ranking member of the party or the military and have access to
top-notch clinics; or a health care tourist who can pay in foreign
currency at a special facility catering to foreigners; or a
documentarian who can be relied upon to produce a lickspittle film
whitewashing the system.
Ordinary Cubans experience the wasteland of the real system. Even
aspirin and Pepto-Bismol can be rare and there's a black market for
them. According to a report in the Canadian newspaper the National Post:
"Hospitals are falling apart, surgeons lack basic supplies and must
reuse latex gloves. Patients must buy their sutures on the black market
and provide bed sheets and food for extended hospital stays."
How could it be any different when Cuba embarked on a campaign of
economic self-sabotage with the revolution of 1959? It went from third
in per capita food consumption in Latin America to near the bottom,
according to a State Department report. Per capita consumption of basic
foodstuff like cereals and meat actually has declined from the 1950s.
There are fewer cars (true of no other country in the hemisphere), and
development of electrical power has trailed every other Latin American
country except Haiti.
But the routine medical care, we're supposed to believe, is superb. The
statistic frequently cited for this proposition is that Cuba has the
lowest infant mortality rate in Latin America. Put aside that the
reflexively dishonest Cuban government is the ultimate source for these
figures. Cuba had the lowest infant mortality rate in Latin America
prior to the revolution and has lost ground to other countries around
the world since. It also has an appallingly high abortion rate, meaning
most problem pregnancies are pre-emptively ended.
Other countries in Latin America have made advances in health without
Cuba's vicious suppression of human rights (which, no doubt, contributes
to the island having the highest suicide rate in Latin America). The way
public health works in Cuba was nicely illustrated by the case of Dr.
Desi Mendoza Rivero, who complained of an outbreak of dengue fever that
the regime preferred to ignore in the late 1990s, and was jailed for his
As is always the case with Cuba, anything that's wrong is blamed on the
United States. If there is a shortage of medicine, well, that's because
of the U.S. embargo. But the United States is not the only country in
the world that sells drugs. Cuba could buy them from Europe or
elsewhere, and the U.S. embargo makes an exception for medicines.
The only reason to fantasize about Cuban health care is to stick a
finger in the eye of the Yanquis. For the likes of Michael Moore, the
true glory of Cuba is less its health care than the fact that it is an
enemy of the United States. That's why romanticizing Cuban medicine
isn't just folly, but itself qualifies as a kind of sickness.